What went wrong with McCain? Nearly everything. But mostly, he ran an
ok GOP campaign for 1952, 1968, 1980...but not 2008. A Cold-War
candidacy in the age of Google?
Let's put aside for a moment the phenomenon of Obama, his eloquence,
equanimity, organizing skills. McCain was old-time religion in the era
of super-churches, a cold warrior when non-state actors are the biggest
variables, a deregulator when even Randian Alan Greenspan questioned
market fundamentalism. He always seemed to be Mel Gibson in Forever Young, a 1940s flyboy transported to and stumbling around in the 1990s.
He simply ran plays from the Grand OLD Party's playbook when, as Obama
was doing on the other side, it was essential to call audibles given
the context of Bush, Katrina, the credit crisis.
First, he had nothing to say about the economic meltdown other than he'd a) cut earmarks (under .005% of the federal budget), b) balance
the budget by the end of his first term (which no one believed and, in
any event, was not very Keynsian when stimuli were needed), and c)
continue Bush's Gilded Age tax policies. Amazing. Bushonomics produced
one-third the job creation of Clinton -- and has helped to create the
current recession -- yet McCain tethered himself to that mast.
Going-down-with-the-ship may seem noble for the scion of admirals but
it's bad economics and worse politics.
Second, instead of talking about real problems, he resorted to a
standard fear-and-smear campaign, more McCarthy than Maverick. Dean
discusses how he'd have been better off running as the McCain of 2000
than the one who daily resorted to guilt-by-ancient-association --
palling around with terrorists, PLO spokesmen, socialists. But none of
that had real traction when the closest thing definitionally to a
socialist was Hank Paulson and voters were more afraid of their bills
Listen: 7D: Howard Dean